24th May, 2008

a quest for malaysian architecture

malaysianarch.jpg

ok, I’m fed up with these complains. I’m sure you have heard them sometimes;

  • architecture in malaysia is different from overseas, here architects are just cad monkeys. they just follow whatever the client wants.
  • over here architects have low salaries than those overseas. imagine a fresh graduate with only rm1600 starting pay..while outside you have lots more 
  • in university you’re taught how to emphasize on design, but in architectural workplace you’re just creating functionalistic buildings
  • malaysian architecture restricts creativity with so-called law of economy. money wins, or is it?

few sad facts about malaysian architecture.

1. most malaysians do not know who is the most famous architect in malaysia. or worst, they don’t even know who the hell is frank gehry. fyi, frank gehry designed the bilbao museum that is now globally famous (yet, malaysians don’t even care about it)

guggenheim museum, bilbao by frank gehry - my non-architecture friends, is this familiar to you?
guggenheim bilbao. world-famous (excluding malaysia?)

2. most recognized buildings in malaysia are designed by foreign architects. do you know that?

petronas towers
our great petronas towers are designed by american cesar pelli (sorry, argentine american architect, thanks narmi)

kuala lumpur international airport
our famous klia, by japanese kisho kurokawa

3. so what is majority of malaysian architects are doing? they’re designing three of the most sad buildings in malaysia.

malaysian shoplots
a) designing sad, boring shoplots. that looks the same all over malaysia. now, is that architecture or a sad building?

malaysian terrace houses
b) the long, depressing terrace houses that all look the same in brochures. that makes us feel more to escape from it rather to live in it. residents buys the idea to live in it, developers take all the money, and malaysian architects? just do it.

malaysian apartments

c) ok, now prison-like apartments. painted a little bit red here and there to look different, but still that you can see everywhere in urban areas of malaysia and you think to yourself: “hey it’s my friend’s condo… oh nope, it just looks like it.”

so, we all got to stop complaining about malaysian architecture and, I am going to start a quest to revolutionise malaysian architecture. so folks, start appreciating architecture, and also critise it! don’t just take it like youre still in high school.

now what you should DO;

1. if you have a chance to commision an architect (just assume youre the owner), don’t let him simply do it. demand your home/project to be a work of art, tell him it’s boring! and ask him to redesign it! remember, great artists need great clients.

2. money. tell the architect the budget earlier and keep it. don’t simply cut the budget in the halfway of the design process! it’s like when you are served the meal and you refund a part of the meal just to save money. so, look at your menu for price first then savour it completely!

3. appreciate the architecture. if you are buying a completed house, ask who is the architect. determine if he is famous or not. or better, don’t buy a complete house. ask your architect friend if there is any plot of land for you to build a home. you might even get it cheaper, without the money going to the developer’s pocket!

4. if you saw the same architect’s work outside, go like this;
you: hey, do you know that new shopping mall downtown is going to open soon?
your friend: yeah, it’s kinda cool and we going to have a new shopping mall^^
you: well, the very same architect designs my house!

so, spread the word. start a quest for malaysia! let us be proud of our modern culture. and put these nice little banner on your blog :)

a quest for malaysian architecture a quest for malaysian architecture a quest for malaysian architecture

Responses

Yang, what you had written in your blog is it come from your own ideas? If so, you are so awesome..hope to have a very creative and innovative architectural friend in the future..all the best to you

Isn’t cesar pelli an argentinian architect?

nice article yang..anyways..i do agree with ur point..but there are great malaysian architects its just that malaysians are not aware of them..heh..

and the majority of architects whom u talked about in ur post outshines this small group of magnificent, brilliant architects..

thats just my opinion though :)

cheers !

pssst~!

The KLIA is designed by Akitek Jururancang (M) Sdn Bhd(the place i’m working now~!) in association with Kisho Kurokawa. its 100% made by malaysian~!

Plus some more~!

Mid Valley City phase 1 is malaysian projects~! Also from Akitek Jururancang Malaysia…..

what do you expect ?

[...] remember the last time I mentioned we need to revolutionise malaysian architecture? well, here is my second step. it appears there is no general knowledge on who is the most famous [...]

erm…i agree wif dis bright ideas young boy a.k.a Yang…u huv awesome n innovative thinking,man…but,how cud u apply ur thinking to our Culture thinking?

congrats… 3rd prize in exhibition huh? N i enjoyed looking at your website, it keeps me fresh de whole day.

That tower on your homepage. Is that London’s Swiss Re Tower (30 St Mary Axe)?

Great sites. Makes me wanna know more bout’ archi. Ganbatte for ur future planning!! Actually i’ve got a question for u. There’s a boy whom actually got an interview for degree of architecture. What should he prepared himself for the interview? Any suggestion??

Hi there,

I was just browsing the internet and I ended up on this forum. I just want to point out something here. I am an architect and currently works in Australia. A few facts that you should know; that as an architect regardless of where you live, is one of those professions that doesnt get paid well enough. Its not just in Malaysia but even in western countries, like US, Australia and so on. Its true that what you get is not much as what any foreign architect earns, but if you think ahead a bit more, the living cost in western countries are much higher than say in Malaysia.
Architecture is by far one of the most expensive degree that one can obtain in University. It takes like 5 years and then another 2 to 3 years of work pratice plus exam until you can be called a licensed architect. Even after that your average salary when compared to other profession is still lower. The term cad monkey does exist also in Australia and in the western world. Unless you are the principal or the owner of the architectural firm, you will never earn the so called “big cash”. That’s the sad but a true fact of our profession. The other thing that, its very hard to get the work/life balance right if you work in architecture. And I am sure, its not just happening in Malaysia, its happening pretty much every where. Just go check in google and enter a keyword like why architect get low salary or etc. You will then see that,there are alot of forums out there from US, Europe, and so on that discuss about this issue. Its a global issue mate. I have been in this Industry since 2001 so its been like 7 years for me and I know I don’t get paid enough. So if you are in to money, architecture is clearly not a profession to choose. Its still possible but requires a lot of hard work, time and dedication if you want to be a successful architect equivalent to Frank Lloyd Wright, Renzo Piano, etc). And to be honest in every generation only few are able to get that far. Its ironic isnt it.

here is some link that can broaden your mind a bit

http://www.architectmagazine.com/industry-news.asp?sectionID=1006&articleID=471543&artnum=1

yes, i totally agree with you, i been working in a architecture firm at kuching half years ago as a design architect, and now i`m studying at the same university as u, haha,meanwhile, i had facing the same problem as u mentioned, even my boss (registered architect) practicing this kind of so-called malaysian architecture culture, moreover, i always argue with my boss and those draftman, most of the time they sai they have the difficulty to generate out my design in 2d, and my boss always said: “wei li u r crazy lah, this kind of design cost a lot u noe, the client will reject it u noe?” but u noe wat, both of us produced our own design and shown to the client and at the end the client chosen mine, so for those architect out there, dare to teach ur client wat is architecture all about, don just comercial lah low cost lah, sien ah….(i`m going to show them this post)

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories